Irish Equal Marriage protest
Muslims, Christians and one Quaker call for a conscience clause
As the Republic of Ireland heads towards a referendum on equal marriage, Irish Muslims and Christians have become united in drafting a petition calling for a “conscience clause” to protect the rights of the religious to refuse recognise same-sex marriage in certain circumstances, and are railing against the “aggressive secularism” of the Bill.
In what is no more than further religious bigotry, the petition makes it obvious that those supporting it do not recognise equal marriage. The wording states;
“We the under-signed, for reasons of faith, consider the state of marriage the exclusive province of a man and a woman. This is the understanding of all revealed religions,”
The petition comes after a number of high-profile cases of a number of Irish businesses refusing service to gay customers, and the proponents of the petition make it perfectly clear they support such people;
“The current wording of the 34th amendment of the Constitution on Marriage Equality and Implementation Bill not only allows for same-sex marriage, but obliges all citizens and residents of Ireland to endorse same-sex marriage or potentially face prosecution. The proposed amendment states marriage may be contracted in accordance of the law by two persons without distinction as to their sex. We therefore respectfully request that Justice Minister Frances Fitzgerald provide for and safeguard the right of people on grounds of ‘conscience’ to abstain from endorsing same-sex marriages while in employment, worship or through social interaction.”
Those backing the petition claim not to be bigoted, and that they recognise the Bill allowing freedom of expression. The wording however obviously tells a different story. If businesses are allowed to discriminate on grounds of sexuality, then they obviously are bigoted and do not recognise freedom of expression.
The petition was started on 4 April 2015 by an amalgam of The Irish Council of Imams, the Galway branch of the Reformed Presbyterian Church. It has since been signed by over 200 members of these groups, and individual Roman Catholic clergy. So in other words, the usual suspects, which one would have expected no less (and no better) from.
Possibly the saddest aspect of all however is the fact that the wording of the petition was drawn up by clerk of the Galway preparative meeting of the Religious Society of Friends, (also known as the Quakers), Richard Kimball. Mr Kimball claimed that a conscience clause would not affect the rights of gay people in Ireland to be served by businesses, then went onto cite the cases of a
Yes, Richard, Dear – it’s called speaking out against hate speech.
The Society of Friends have yet to either endorse or reject the petition. However that a Quaker should even draft such an odious and obviously bigoted petition, seeking to legitimise homophobia, is indeed depressing, The Society of Friends never stood against nor sought a conscience clause in either England’s Same Sex Marriage Act, nor Scotland’s Marriage and Civil Partnerships Act. It seems therefore that Mr Kimball may very well be out of step with the views of his own faith.
Thankfully the petitioners may have missed the boat, for as the referendum debate is well under way, any such clause is now unlikely to be included.
The English bill proposed in the consultation would have forbidden same sex marriage in church, and it was the Quaker response to the consultation which resulted in it being permitted. But Ireland Yearly Meeting is rather more conservative than Britain Yearly Meeting.
Really sad to hear that, Clare. Although I’m an atheist I have a really soft spot for the Society of Friends. I’ve always found them to be the least judgemental and the kindest of all faiths.
Marriage equality referendum – a letter from Quakers in Dublin
Posted by BQ Web Committee
This letter was sent on behalf of Dublin Monthly Meeting. We, Eustace Street Meeting – formally known as ‘Dublin Preparative Meeting (PM)’ are a constituent meeting of Dublin Monthly Meeting*.
“Dublin Quakers met on 15 April 2015 and discussed the forthcoming referendum on marriage equality. There was a diversity of views in the meeting as there is among Irish Quakers generally.
At the heart of Friends’ Christian practice is the freedom to think and express opinions and to speak or vote in seeking the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
The founder of Quakerism, George Fox, said as early as 1697 ‘marriage is the work of the Lord only … for it is in God’s ordinance and not man’s … we marry none; it is the Lord’s work and we are but witnesses.’ Since the introduction of civil partnerships, Quakers in Dublin have conducted Meetings for Worship to celebrate the committed relationships of our Members.
As Christians, Quakers are deeply committed to equality, recognising that of God in every person. It is fundamental to Christianity that we should seek to love our neighbours as ourselves.
Signed on behalf of: Dublin Monthly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends.
Alan G. Harrison